Paper Assignment: Letter to a
Public Official
Due Date: November 24th
One means by which citizens communicate with public officials and government
agencies is through letter writing.For
this assignment, you will draft a detailed letter to your representative
in the House of Representatives or one of your two U.S. senators on a national
public policy issue.In the letter
you will ask the official to adopt a specific position and to take some
kind of action.Your letter should
be at least three pages (plus the cover page as described below), typed,
double-spaced (in 12-point font with one-inch margins).Please
do not write more than five pages without discussing the paper with your
TA or the professor.Note that this
is a required assignment for the course and the grade will be included
in the calculation of your final course average.Failure
to submit the paper results in an F on the assignment, which is one-quarter
of your course grade.
The letter must be based upon research.To
begin with, you must study the policy issue itself, so you can develop
the strongest argument for the position you advocate and address possible
objections or counter-arguments to your position.Then
you must decide which elected official to contact and find the correct
mailing address.(Whether you
actually mail it will be your choice; before you mail it you should wait
for comments from the instructor grading the assignment.)The
cover
page of the assignment should include your name and section, identify
the policy issue, and identify the official to whom you are sending the
letter.The letter itself should
include a proper heading with the official’s address and formal salutation.Failure
to identify a specific official, include a proper mailing address, or sign
the letter will cost you points on the assignment.
In the letter you seek to persuade the official to support your position
by the strength of your argument.Begin
with an introduction in which you state in the first sentence what
specifically you want the official to do and follow with a preview of the
argument that makes up the body of your letter.(Note
that urging the recipient to speak out or support position is not sufficient
– specify the action, such as voting for a specific bill by its number,
that you want the official to take.)The
letter should proceed in order through the following three steps:(1)
Your argument for why the official should act as you suggest.Your
argument may focus on moral and/or practical issues.Some
possible arguments include:the current
policy has the wrong goal or purpose; the current policy is not accomplishing
its purpose; the current policy is too short-sighted and ignores the long-run
public interest; or there may be a better way to achieve the same goal.(This
list is not complete.Feel free
to develop other arguments.)Whatever
kind of argument you make, it must be supported by appropriate data or
examples.While you may include
personal experiences as part of the argument, it must be based primarily
on your research.(2)The
counter-argument or objections to your position.Every
issue has at least two sides.Some
people will disagree with you for moral, practical, or political reasons.(Note
that in an actual letter to a public official, you would not ordinarily
include counter arguments, but you must discuss them here to demonstrate
your awareness of other viewpoints).If
there are numerous counter-arguments, pick several of the most compelling
ones and explain them carefully.Note
that there is a danger of reducing the opposing side to a caricature.To
avoid this, it is essential to quote or cite opposing sources.(3)Your
answer to the counter-arguments.Show
the official why the objections to your position are not convincing.
4.Broadening
employer-based health insurance/creating a tax credit to let individuals
purchase private health insurance;
5.Raising
taxes on wealthy Americans by ending parts of the Bush tax cut/lowering
the capital gains tax and/or corporate taxes;
6.Reforming
“No Child Left Behind”;
7.Increasing
off-shore oil drilling/building new nuclear power plants;
8.Mandatory
measures (specify which ones) to reduce green-house gas emissions;
9.Comprehensive
immigration reform.
You
may choose to advocate either side of any issue listed.If
action on the issue already has been completed by one chamber of Congress,
your letter should be directed to an official in the other chamber.
Many Internet research sources are suitable for this assignment, but be
aware that many sites are sponsored by advocacy groups and their objectivity
and accuracy cannot be assumed.Watch
out for bias! Good starting
points for basic information include nationaljournal.com and major news
media web sites such as cnn.com.When
you turn in the assignment, attach a photocopy of all articles, internet
downloads, and other short published material you use.Failure
to attach the material will result in a late penalty for the assignment
until the material is submitted and an F if the material is not submitted
within one week of the instructor’s request.Instructors
reserve the right to ask you to show them any other material (such as longer
reports or pamphlets) you have used that you do not attach to the letter.
Although you must draw upon appropriate sources, your letter should consist
mostly of analysis, argument, and/or interpretation in your own words.You
may quote directly not more than ten linesin
the entire letter.If we find that
you are lifting more than ten lines from your sources (including language
only slightly changed from the original), we will treat that as plagiarism.While
that is an academic violation at Hunter College, in this case your letter
will be returned without a grade and we will treat the assignment as though
you did not do it, computing an F into your course average.If
we suspect deliberate plagiarism, we may require that you submit your paper
to a plagiarism detection service.Evidence
of plagiarism in such cases will result in formal disciplinary action.
Note that all information derived from your sources must be cited, even
when you have put it into your own words.Citations
should follow the in-text parenthetical format, with full bibliographic
information at the end of the letter.Citations
to the Internet should be sufficiently specific so as to allow a reader
to arrive at the same web page where you found the information.
The paper is due Monday, November 24th.If
your discussion session meets Monday, the paper must be turned in there.For
all others, the papers must be submitted at the end of the lecture that
day in Room 714 HW.Late papers
(without a documented, valid reason) will be penalized one full letter
grade for each day late.This
includes papers turned in on the due date after the time indicated.You
may not submit papers via e-mail or fax.Late
papers should be left in our respective mailboxes in the department office
(1724 HW); never leave a paper under an office door.Note
that you will have the option to rewrite the paper to earn a better grade,
but only if you submit the original paper on time.Failure
to attach source material not only incurs the late penalty but costs you
the option of rewriting the paper.