Grading Guide for Examinations
In-class essay exams will be graded according to several criteria. To
make it possible for you to best prepare, it is appropriate that you know
what these criteria are. The criteria, which have been adapted from the
CUNY Proficiency Examination Task 1 Scoring Guide, are listed below. I
will assign a score on a 4.0 scale for each category, give double weight
to the second criterion (content), average the scores to arrive at the
exam grade, and convert this to a letter grade.
(1) Organization that produces a focused response to the question:
The essay should include an introduction that states the main claim(s)
or point(s) of your essay and previews the essay itself, a main body structured
to respond to the question as posed (i.e., that follows the order of the
question), and a conclusion. Further, the essay should feature suitable
paragraph divisions and topic sentences, with coherent connections among
the parts of the essay. Only material relevant to the question should be
included.
(2) Completeness and accuracy: The essay should respond to all
parts of the question, demonstrate full understanding of the arguments
of any authors under discussion, and offer specific examples as appropriate
to substantiate points. Names, dates, and events relevant to the essay
should be accurate.
(3) Clear and effective communication: The essay should communicate ideas clearly, using a vocabulary appropriate for the course and the discipline; grammatical conventions should be used. The distinction between your voice and the author(s) under discussion should be clear. I do not penalize spelling errors on in-class tests unless they obscure the meaning of a sentence.